PlanSA Development Refusal: Statutory Appeal Procedures and Key Considerations in the SA ERD Court
Statutory Review and Appeal Pathways Following a Development Refusal
When a development application lodged through PlanSA is refused by a relevant authority, such as a council Assessment Panel (CAP) or the State Commission Assessment Panel (SCAP), or is granted subject to conditions that affect the project’s viability, applicants generally have statutory rights of review or appeal. Where an application has been decided by an Assessment Manager acting as the relevant authority, section 202 of the Planning, Development and Infrastructure Act 2016 (PDI Act 2016) allows the applicant to apply to the relevant assessment panel for an internal review of a “prescribed matter”, or to appeal directly to the Environment, Resources and Development Court (ERD Court). An internal review application generally needs to be made within one month of receiving notice, depending on the council’s policy and the PlanSA application form. An applicant who chooses an internal review should keep the 2-month appeal deadline described below in mind, and should not assume that a review automatically extends that deadline. Decisions of the State Planning Commission or SCAP have their own review procedures (for example, a decision review request in restricted development), which should be confirmed with PlanSA.
The ERD Court is South Australia’s specialist court dealing with planning, heritage, building and environmental disputes. In merits appeals, the Court reconsiders whether the proposal complies with the relevant provisions of the Planning and Design Code, and has the power to affirm, vary or set aside the original decision.
Statutory Timeframes and Lodgement Requirements
Strict time limits apply to appeals under South Australian planning law. According to the Courts Administration Authority and section 202 of the PDI Act 2016:
Applicants / Appellants: An appeal to the ERD Court must generally be lodged within 2 months after receiving notice of the decision. If the deadline has been missed, an application for an extension of time can be made to the Court, which may grant it in special circumstances.
Representors (Restricted Development only): A representor who is entitled to appeal must lodge the appeal within 15 business days after the date of the decision.
Other specific orders: Some orders carry tighter time limits; for example, an appeal against an emergency order under section 155 of the PDI Act generally must be lodged within 14 days after the order is received, unless an extension is granted.
To commence an appeal, the appellant must complete a Notice of Appeal, attach the decision being appealed, and pay the Court fee. Once the Notice of Appeal has been accepted and sealed by the Court, a copy must be provided to the authority whose decision is being appealed within a short period set by the Court (currently stated by the Courts Administration Authority as three days). Court fees are adjusted periodically, and the exact amounts should be confirmed with the Courts Administration Authority or your legal practitioner.
The Conciliation Conference Framework
Once an appeal is lodged with the ERD Court, the matter generally goes through pre-hearing procedures first, including pre-hearing conferences or a conciliation conference arranged by the Court. In conciliation, the applicant, expert planning advisers and council representatives can explore possible design compromises, amended building envelopes or agreed draft conditions. If the parties reach agreement, the Court may make consent orders on those terms, which can grant a revised proposal development approval without a full hearing. If conciliation does not resolve the dispute, the matter proceeds to evidence exchange, expert witness evidence and a formal hearing.
Cost Implications and Pre-Appeal Considerations
An ERD Court appeal gives the applicant an independent forum outside the local council, but it involves legal costs, expert witness costs and holding costs. Appellants generally engage planning consultants, traffic or acoustic experts and legal counsel to present their evidence. Because cost rules, the Court’s procedural directions and the prospects of each case vary, landowners should confirm their options with a planning lawyer and development adviser before deciding whether to redesign, reapply or appeal.
Sources
Lodging an appeal | Courts Administration Authority of South Australia
Application for assessment panel review of assessment manager’s decision | PlanSA
Retaining Walls (emergency order appeal period) | Law Handbook SA
Illustrative image only — not a photograph of a Cyberate PM project. Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels.
About the author
Lin Yuan
Expert property development and project management insights.
Not Sure Whether Your Site Stacks Up?
Send us the address and your goal. We will identify the first planning, buildability and feasibility questions before you commit further capital.

