Building Encroachments in SA: The Encroachments Act 1944 vs Voluntary Realignment

04-11-2026
Building Encroachments in SA: The Encroachments Act 1944 vs Voluntary Realignment 1

What Constitutes a Legal Building Encroachment?

During property development and ongoing asset management, structures that intrude across title boundaries are a recurring legal and planning issue. Under section 2 of the Encroachments Act 1944 (SA), an overhanging structure, or a part of a building below ground that crosses the boundary, may be an encroachment where it is a substantial structure of a permanent character.

Statutory encroachments cover a broad range of physical elements, not only the main walls of a building at ground level. Overhanging eaves, subterranean footings extending into neighbouring soil, and retaining walls built across title lines may all qualify as encroaching structures under South Australian law. The guidance published by the Legal Services Commission of South Australia indicates that an ordinary boundary fence is unlikely to be treated as a structure for the purposes of the Act. However, the Supreme Court has held that a concrete driveway (Clarke v Wilkie [1977] SASR 134), and a combined structure of a brush fence sitting on a concrete plinth with a retaining wall (Hogarth v Karp [2013] SASC 159), are structures for the purposes of the Act.

Statutory Remedies Under the Encroachments Act 1944

Where an encroachment exists and the adjoining neighbours cannot reach a commercial resolution, either owner may apply to the Supreme Court of South Australia under section 4(2) of the Act. Depending on the circumstances of the case, the Court may grant one or more of the following remedies:

  • Compensation: An order for compensation to be paid to the owner on whose land the structure encroaches; section 5 of the Act sets out how compensation is calculated;

  • Transfer or Lease: An order that the encroached land be transferred or leased to the encroaching owner;

  • Removal: An order for the removal of the encroachment.

In making its decision, the Court considers a number of factors (section 4(3)), including whether the application was made by the adjacent owner or the encroaching owner, the situation and value of the land and the nature and extent of the encroachment, the character of the encroaching building and its use, the loss or damage incurred or likely to be incurred by the adjacent owner, the loss the encroaching owner would incur in removing the encroachment, and the circumstances in which the encroachment was made.

If the parties dispute whether an encroachment exists, they may arrange a survey, or apply to the Supreme Court for a survey to be ordered (section 10).

In addition, under section 11 of the Act, if one owner (usually the owner whose land is encroached upon) has taken other legal action in connection with the matter, such as trespass proceedings, the other owner may apply for a court order that the matter be dealt with under the Encroachments Act 1944 alone. This provision helps avoid multiple proceedings.

Retaining Wall Encroachments and Development Approvals

According to the Law Handbook SA, a retaining wall is a particular type of boundary structure. If any part of a retaining wall, including its footings, extends onto neighbouring property, it is an encroachment, and the Encroachments Act 1944 (SA) provides for adjustment of boundaries or compensation. The owners may negotiate a resolution, or apply to the Supreme Court.

From a regulatory perspective, any excavation or filling of land associated with constructing a building or other significant structure will usually need development approval, and the details of the retaining wall for the excavation or fill must be included in the development application for the proposed structure. Where a retaining wall is built independently, for example for landscaping, or where an existing retaining wall is to be demolished, repaired or altered, whether development approval is required depends on the nature of the works and the requirements of the council. As a general guide, a retaining wall that retains a difference in ground levels of one metre or less usually does not need development approval, although it may still need approval in particular zones or council areas, and approval will be needed where the retaining wall and a fence on it together exceed 2.1 metres in height. These thresholds should be confirmed against the current rules and with the local council.

In addition, where the construction of a retaining wall will affect the stability of the neighbour’s land (for example, fill within 600 mm of the boundary, or an excavation that intersects the prescribed slope plane), section 139 of the Planning, Development and Infrastructure Act 2016 requires a Form 1 Initial Notice to be served on the neighbouring owner at least 20 business days before the work starts.

Voluntary Resolution and Boundary Realignment Pathways

Court proceedings in the Supreme Court may involve substantial cost and extended timelines for both owners. As a result, adjoining landowners in practice often prefer to negotiate a voluntary outcome, such as a boundary realignment or an agreed land transfer, to resolve boundary anomalies.

In South Australia, an alteration of boundaries is a form of land division and involves planning approval and title registration. Because site constraints, mortgage encumbrances, easement rights and survey requirements vary considerably between properties, the specific application procedures, documentation and consent pathways should be confirmed with a qualified surveyor, legal practitioner or conveyancer.

Sources

Illustrative image only — not a photograph of a Cyberate PM project. Photo by Thirdman on Pexels.

About the author

Lin Yuan

Expert property development and project management insights.

Not Sure Whether Your Site Stacks Up?

Send us the address and your goal. We will identify the first planning, buildability and feasibility questions before you commit further capital.